A Vatican report has acknowledged that many LGBTQ+ Catholics experience isolation, stigma and emotional distress within the Church.
The document, released on 5 May by a group of theologians as part of the Synod of Bishops process, is believed to be the first official Vatican publication to include detailed personal testimonies from LGBTQ+ Catholics.
Drawing on first-hand accounts, the report highlights what it describes as “solitude, anguish and stigma” experienced by people with same-sex attraction and their families, as well as the complex tension between faith and sexuality.
Authors say the testimonies reveal “both lacerations and longings, hope and pain”, pointing to a lived reality in which individuals often feel marginalised within their own religious communities.
The report also reflects critically on past Church approaches to LGBTQ+ issues, particularly so-called “conversion” or “reparative” therapies. It notes these practices have had “devastating effects” and contributed to “profound suffering” among those subjected to them.
Such experiences, the report suggests, have deepened feelings of isolation and contributed to what some described as a “disintegrating separation between faith and sexuality”.
In one testimony, a participant described the personal impact of efforts to change sexual orientation, while others spoke of being encouraged to suppress or conceal their identity in order to remain within Church life.
Despite its candid tone, the report stops short of proposing any changes to Catholic doctrine on sexuality or marriage. Instead, it calls for a renewed emphasis on pastoral care, dialogue and listening to lived experiences.
The authors argue that bridging the gap between established teaching and the realities faced by LGBTQ+ Catholics will require a more holistic approach, incorporating insights from psychology and human experience alongside theology.
Advocates have described the inclusion of personal testimonies as unprecedented for a Vatican document. The Rev James Martin, a prominent Jesuit priest and LGBTQ+ ministry founder, said it marked the first time such accounts had been presented in detail in an official publication.
Observers say the move reflects a broader effort within the Church’s global synod process to become more “listening and participatory”, although they caution that the report’s impact on everyday parish life remains uncertain.
The report emerges in a context of ongoing debate within the Catholic Church over LGBTQ+ inclusion. While recent years have seen gestures towards greater openness - including informal blessings for some same-sex couples - official teaching continues to define marriage as between a man and a woman.
As a result, many LGBTQ+ Catholics continue to navigate what the report itself identifies as a tension between doctrinal certainty and pastoral welcome, a divide that has often led to experiences of marginalisation or “double lives”.
Scene was founded in Brighton in 1993, at a time when news stories about Pride protests were considered radical.
Since then, Scene has remained proudly independent, building a platform for queer voices. Every subscription helps us to report on the stories that matter to LGBTQ+ people across the UK and beyond.
Your support funds our journalists and contributes to Pride Community Foundation’s grant-making and policy work.
Member discussion